React useState resets when switching browser tabs - how to persist state?

Can you move the state higher up?

I might not be understanding the problem but what about storing the page state in a param? eg.

?page=3

and have your component read from that instead of internal state?

It's the very first thing that happens in the page's default export; do I have to move it into the _app itself to preserve it? I guess I naively thought there might be something like "heydon'tchangethis" I could flag.
There isn't even a side effect, it's literally just got a default state and clicks change it back and forth.


My experience with params has led me to believe the page could no longer be static if that were the case; if it can, would I just use the router instead of props to ascertain that?
(Thank you both for responding, by the way, and so quickly
😃 )

Yeah, if you use query params, you can no longer statically build the pages but you could rely on SSR.

Another approach is to use route params instead.

And statically build the pages.

Is there a technological reason it would do that in general? I don't remember other components losing state (like, say, entries into a form field) set to e.target.value onChange) but maybe I just wasn't paying attention.

If I am on a "page" (say, the third component) and navigate to another browser tab and come back, it looks like the state resets (it defaults to 0, the first "page") and I lose my progress.

This shouldn’t happen unless you have a browser extension that “shuts down” tabs.

It’s weird that navigating to a different browser tab and returning to another tab would be causing this tbh.
Do your tabs refresh’ when you visit them? Browser extensions? Or are you using something like SWR?
https://swr.vercel.app/

I just tested it with the pretend page with form fields like
const [page, setPage] = useState(2) instead of the default
0 and tried typing into them and then went to another browser tab and came back and they, too reset....
I believe in local testing that there are renders triggered, that's not new to me, but usually it's just a repaint (so like if I had a useEffect with a fetch, that might get called again)....but this just goes back to whatever the default is

Nothing is even being fetched, so now fetch and now SWR.

I have AdBlock Plus is all and have tried deactivating it for the page and removing it entirely, no difference

It's just

{ page == 0 && <OneThing> }
{ page == 1 && <TwoThing> } etc. (simplifying the names for clarity)

Have you tried opening tabs in incognito mode so no extensions should interfere with the page and see if it happens then?

Or another browser?

I have. I actually straight-up uninstalled it, and tried in Firefox and Edge.
I checked all my component keys as well to make sure I didn't typo them out of uniqueness.

I suspected it might be Framer Motion because of AnimatePresence and just the "illusion" of certain things appearing and disappearing but it doesn't bear out in the markup and also anything that's not in them that includes the state also resets.

That’s a good guess. What if you remove framer-motion from that page?

I am surprised to learn that that didn't make a difference

Any chance I could play with your code?

Under normal circumstances I'd be happy and relieved to but there's enough in there that would break my NDA. (I do appreciate how annoyingly that binds the open call for help)

Ah yes, I understand.

Normally I'd just explain the reset away if anyone asked but it's onboarding with like nine pages so you really don't want anyone losing that progress.
I will definitely let you both know here if I learn anything. I have tried scraping out any mentions of the state on the child components in case they "received" it enough to trigger something but no dice.

I would move the state into the URL, e.g.:

<base page>/page/2

, and use

getStaticProps

in

<base page folder>/[page].js

to build the pages you need. Then you would have to make sure to update the URL using the browser's History API. You should also probably fetch that the updated page by listening for the update in URL.

You would generate a number of very similar pages, so the total size of your site would increase, but you would get the effect you want.

Yeah, that’s what I suggested earlier as well:

Another approach is to use route params instead.

I would agree with that approach. 🙂

Ah, yes, true, sorry for not recognizing that ^_^

No, no, no worries. All good. ❤️ I also didn’t expand much on it.

One of the reasons I kept them as child components (representing pages) on one real page is they all have forms, and the idea was to do a multi-page form where each legitimate submission fed back to the overarching state at the top of the (parent) file.
If they're separate real pages I believe I then have to move from unmounting children into page transitions and move from a single (albeit busy) state to a form context provider.

Still investigating, but in either case I continue to appreciate the extra eyes
😃

OY! It's one of those forehead-slapping ones. And if I'd only been able to share the code I could have spared you both the sacrifice of time from my oversight.
In this onboarding, because it's an onboarding, you have to be logged in. I had a Spinner component from Sanity UI in place so there was something to indicate, and it was a previous state from the auth library ( i.e
{ isLoading, user, error } ) in one of those kinds of patterns.
Somehow I did the same thing twice but in a different way, not realizing the original was in place (must have forgotten overnight and re-worked it in the morning, again, for the first time
😃 ) -- and you know what I did? I set the whole parent page functional component to conditionally return.
Like, literally, instead of having a line, I had the line, then the main functions' return -- so in checking to see if the user's state coming in from the provider was valid it showed or hid the entire mess.

I definitely owe you both a pizza or a drink. Just...wow. This one's not great for my impostor syndrome. At least the walk of shame will constitute exercise and keep me from becoming too sedentary.

Everyone brainfarts once in a while. 😄 ❤️

Yeah I just get self conscious when I don't keep track of how many brain beans I've been eating and strike up conversations with people trapped in a brain elevator with me 😆